Search This Blog

Thursday, December 28, 2017

Why the FRDI Bill is so toxic

You may have heard that the cabinet has approved the Financial Resolution and Deposit Insurance (FRDI) bill and tabled it in the Lok Sabha. The bill was referred to a joint parliamentary committee without any discussion in the Lok Sabha. The committee is expected to place their report on the bill in the Lok Sabha in 2018.  If passed, in my view the implementation of the bill will destabilize the already worrying situation in our country :'

1.    The bill refers to a bail in by depositors – that means that a bank which is short of cash by having given away our money in massive loans that the promotors refuse to pay back (like Vijay Mallya), may recoup some of its losses by refusing to return part of or all of our money in the bank. That money may be converted to shares in the loss-making bank. Until the bank becomes profitable again, if at all, and the shares appreciate greatly in value, we will be unable to have our money that was in the bank, back.

2.     The money covered by insurance paid by the banks amounts to only Rs. 1 lakh per account holder in one bank. Yes, if you have another account in another bank that is separately insured for 1 lakh rupees also. Ofcourse some 67 % of the account holders in our public-sector banks have deposits amounting to less than 1 lakh so they are covered by this insurance. But the remaining 33 % presumably lower middle class and above will have their entire life savings in banks amounting to tens of lakhs possibly, especially soon after retirement.

3.     Atleast 12 % of all loans given by public sector banks have become unviable – wont be paid back by the loan takers. In terms of amount of money in loans that have become bad, figures ranging from 10 – 20 lakh crore rs. are being quoted in the media. For perspective, total amount of deposits in public sector banks are 111 lakh crores. The money loaned out is 81 lakh crores. The banks have borrowed money from other sources to the tune of 12 lakh crores. Whatever the math, it is being said by all concerned that the public-sector banks have become short of cash and are unable to make new loans to industry and agriculture in keeping with demand. This has badly hit economic growth in our country, but even more seriously, it puts our money in the bank at risk should the bank fail.

4.     For decades, the government has not gone far enough to improve the functioning of our public-sector banks. Instead, politicians have focused on milking the banks for large loans to their own enterprises and to the companies that fund them for elections – enterprises which have no intention of paying the loan back fully. So farmers owing a few thousands or lakhs to the banks are hounded and their land confiscated while companies with thousands of crores in outstanding loans are given more and more loans. So some of our money given for safe custody in banks has already disappeared in this loot. The amount of this lost money has become so large lately that it is affecting the giving of new loans and perhaps may eventually one day lead to the bank being unable to pay us back fully when we want to withdraw our cash.

5.     We have even earlier been aware of all this, but taken comfort in the implicit sovereign guarantee that our government will not let any commercial bank fail. And it has not. When some bank has been in trouble, RBI and Government have stepped in and merged it with another bank and so on. Cash injections have been made by Governments into public sector banks to help them meet their obligations. But with this proposed FRDI Bill, that sovereign guarantee appears to be a thing of the past – the govt. says in this bill that if your bank is in trouble, it is your money that should be used to help it stabilize.

6.     If this comes to pass with one or more banks, what of the depositors dependent for their living expenses on their bank account or on cash reserves to run their business ? What is their fault in this looting ? If it is essentially a fault of careless or corrupt governance, the government should be bailing out banks and setting right their governance. Of course Government should not be misusing our hard-earned taxes and bank deposits to first loot from deposits (and taxes) and then use some of those taxes to keep bailing out banks who keep giving loans to looters, and so on. It should be taking many corrective steps to minimize this loot and to make more loans possible to those genuinely putting up businesses and industries, and to help make agriculture more profitable by helping improve farm productivity.

7.     So has the government been taking any of the steps suggested by many committees ? The main supervision of banks is by the governing bodies of those banks.. these are stuffed full of government appointees, who perhaps use their positions to extract more loans for cronies. Many reforms such as having separate MDs and Chairmen of Banks, carefully making new appointments to bank governing bodies, making available better credit rating systems, and so on have been repeatedly mooted. But many positions on bank governing boards even now wait for months and years for government to approve of names suggested by RBI. Naming willful defaulters (those who have capacity to pay back loans but are choosing not to pay them) has been asked for repeatedly by courts in response to PILs but was resisted by government as well as RBI. Critics rightfully say that those borrowing thousands of crores from banks – our money, should be transparently rated, their project proposals put in the public domain, and their loan payback performance also publicly available. But this is far from being implemented.

8.     Instead, the agencies which can help monitor, investigate and stem the loot are more and more staffed with corrupt or lackadaisical people, or the positions are simply not filled for years, especially by the present government – CBI, central vigilance commission, central information commissioner, lokayukta, and so on..

9.     The FRDI bill envisages the creation of a Resolution Corporation that will rate the sickness of banks and take them over as required. It will manage their affairs and try to make them solvent if possible, or else sell their assets. These functions have been performed by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) all along. To many commentators there is no justification for creating the Resolution Corporation to take over functions of the RBI. The only advantage to the government appears to be that the resolution corporation will have appointees made by the finance ministry and thus more directly controlled by it compared with the RBI which is an independent statutory body. And it is such government / political control itself which has brought the banks to their present pass !

10.   I have sent a mail to Lok sabha and Rajya sabha MPs of my area asking them to desist from voting for this bill when it is put to discussion and voting. I used this well drafted mail at this link - http://www.repealfrdi.net/ they send you a mail to your id (can take 2-3 hours) and you press the link to send it to the MPs. I have heard there is a petition ongoing at change.org to repeal this bill and I will find and sign it too.

11.   Some people wrote back to say they shared some of these concerns and had been trying to read up more. one person wrote back : ‘The Govt has issued a series of ads in the newspapers that deposits are safe. This was started during the Guj elections. I checked my known sources & have been told that this kind of thing cannot be done in India which is a savings oriented economy.’ Another person wrote back : ‘But last week finance minister Mr Jaitly cleared these same points on India TV and said that it's not true, all is fake and created by opposition. The government going to make law for more secure the money of depositers in bank.’

12.   Here is the background on how the FRDI bill came to be drafted in its present form : Post 2008 bail out of American banks, the US govt. felt they cannot do this again. So they proposed to the G-7 group of countries the bail in clause that money from the depositors of the failing bank be used to make it solvent again. (in contrast, bail out means some external party – usually the government gives money to the bank to make it solvent again). The G-7 group of countries accepted that clause and further proposed it to the G-20 group of countries – India among them. This clause was accepted by this group as well, and several countries have reportedly now made similar laws as in india – reportedly they include Canada, UK and the EU. The Financial Stability Board which was created to guide this process internationally has apparently a model law that india has copied more or less verbatim.

13.   But these countries offer much more security to their citizens compared to in our country. To begin with the deposit insurance in the UK and Germany is 3 times that of the average yearly wage in those countries. In Canada and the US, it is 5 times the average yearly wage in those countries. In India the average yearly wage is 1.25 lakh rupees, so our deposit insurance does not even cover one year’s wage. I guess it should be raised to atleast 4 lakh rupees to be equivalent to the UK norm, but would entail more payments for this insurance by the banks and therefore more payments by us as fees to our banks. Secondly, these countries offer a fantastic level of health care to all their citizens, old age pensions (which in Germany is 3000 euros a month – 2.25 lakh rupees !), and many other support systems. In India these systems and services are very inadequate. Especially the middle class onwards, everyone save government servants, are critically dependant on their savings in banks.

14.   Experts say that another difference between these countries and ours is that most deposits in their banks are by wholesalers – i.e. large institutions, credit unions, insurance companies and so on. These large institutions are better able to protect themselves. In our country most deposits are retail – i.e. by the end customer. So India should never have copied this bill from an international model which is totally unsuited for our country.

15.   The bail in clause has already been used in Cyprus in 2013. Cyprus is one of the EU countries, albeit a small one. The banks in that country had bought a lot of bonds from Greek Banks as investments. When the Greek economy started sinking those bonds became worthless and the Cyprus banks had no money to transact normal business with their customers. The bail in clause was invoked and customers could only have access to 1 lakh euros – the amount covered by their deposit guarantee. Some 40 % of the deposits above that amount were converted to shares of those failed banks. Another 20 % were kept in reserve for more conversion to shares if the bank needed to do so. Another 30 % was put in compulsory FDs for periods ranging from 3 months to 1 year. So one presumes the customers of those banks got only 10 % of their deposits back immediately, apart from 1 lakh euros, and another 50 % after a period of time when the situation had stabilized. But 40 % of every deposit was gone for a long time until the banks would be profitable and their share prices rose.

16.   The bail in clause was also used by the Iceland Government in 2009 (the term may not actually have existed then but the same strategy was employed). This is another small country in the Eurozone. The banks there raised money from Europe by offering crazy interest rates to the tune of 15 % and so on. The Iceland banks then went shopping for equally crazy assets all over the world, including sports teams and so on. The banks crashed after a few years. The government fully guaranteed (after the bank crash) the full amounts of deposits of the DOMESTIC customers. But it refused to honour the deposits of lakhs of customers who had transacted with those bank branches in countries such as the UK, Denmark and others. Those governments were agile enough to quickly freeze the assets of the failed banks in their countries, and thus retrieve for their citizens atleast some of their money.

17.   So obviously this bill should be repealed in full – rejected by parliament or withdrawn by the Government. It is not enough in my view to delete just 1-2 offending clauses – because they can easily be inserted back in after a few years by a majority single party led government. But that is not the end of our troubles with our banks – which can still fail and cause us grief. Government spokespersons and people who drafted the bill have said that therefore the bill does not really make things worse than they already are. But I think they are obfuscating the reality – today a bank may fail and may end up losing the money of some of its depositors. But depending on the losses, some or most may get their money back. But a bail in provision as per the FRDI bill would lock in the money of all depositors so that the bank may continue to survive.

18.   I have tried to study what positive steps can be taken so these must be the focus of what we demand that the Government do in this matter. The last RBI Governor’s tenure was from Sep 2013 to Aug 2016. Early on, he got RBI to minutely study the actual asset position of banks – i.e. how many loans had actually gone bad (as the banks were not declaring them and were hiding their actual financial position). With that report in hand by early 2015, RBI constituted a Banks Board Bureau with many eminent persons on board who set about to find talented people of integrity to head the banks or serve in their boards. Sadly, the Government has not worked in tandem with the Bureau to quickly fill bank boards with appropriate appointees.

19.   RBI and the Banks Board Bureau also worked on many other measures to recover some of these bad loans called NPAs (Non Performing Assets). From selling off some of the assets of failed companies, to restructuring the loans to giving an emergency cash injection in a few cases where the company could be helped to continue its business and return the funds by and by. But the RBI Governor, Raghuram Rajan, who was in the thick of this process of bad loans cleanup was not given another term after his 3-year term was over. This was a delicate task he was doing and many people felt he should have been allowed to complete it.

20.   In fact, there have been 24 Governors since the inception of the Reserve Bank and 12 of them have served terms of 4-7 years each. In previous regimes, the governor appointed by Congress Party was given an extension by the then BJP government, and that appointed by the BJP government was given an extension by the Congress Government. That must have been because the work they were then doing was felt to be more important than which regime appointed the Governor. But this BJP government not only did not extend the term of the RBI Governor appointed by the Congress Government before them, it allowed Subramaniam Swamy to endlessly belittle the RBI governor publicly with unfounded trivia. This was a new low in independent india, for the RBI and its Governors have been widely respected throughout its history not only in india but internationally too.

21.   The committee set up by the Finance Ministry to prepare the FRDI bill submitted its draft just after Rajan left the post of Governor, RBI, so his comments on this bill are not available to us. The timing may have been deliberate I think, as the RBI was already fully into the very issues that are the subject matter of this bill. The bill seeks to override RBI and give all its powers in the case of failing banks to a new entity – the resolution corporation. So not only we the tax payers will be asked to pay for a whole new bureaucracy, that new entity will have zero institutional experience to begin with. It will also have highly centralized powers against which no appeal can be made to the courts or any other entity except the highly overworked company law board ! So we must ask not only for the FRDI bill to be rejected / withdrawn, we must also ask that RBI must be enabled to continue its work on cleaning up the bad assets of banks, rather than the often adversarial position the Finance Ministry takes on these issues.

22.   RBI and the Finance Ministry must set up a credit rating agency which rates the credit position not only of companies that apply for loans but also of their promoters and sister concerns. The reports of this agency must be online, as also the appraisal reports by banks of the criteria they used to pass or reject specific loans. Ofcourse this may be done to begin with, for large loans. This may sound outlandish but such is the stranglehold of corruption including by bank officers, corporates, bureaucrats and politicians, that there is no other way to combat this phenomena. This suggestion has been repeatedly made by Prashant Bhushan who represented the first PIL on this subject in the 1990s. The petition was launched by H D Shourie, Arun Shourie’s father who had spearheaded a respected public organization called Common Cause. That and similar PILs also by Prashant Bhushan and Swaraj Abhiyan have continued to this day and it is a result of some of this work that the NPAs have come to light as much as they have.

23.   Those who have looted our money and brought our banks (and consequently our economy) to the precipice must be prosecuted and awarded exemplary punishments. But for this the institutions who can help do this need to be staffed fully with competent people, and left alone by the Government to do their job – RBI, CVC, CIC, Loayukta and most importantly, the CBI.

24.   A similar legislation to the FRDI bill has been adopted for EU as a whole, applicable to 28 Eurozone countries. Known as the Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive, the legislation is the centerpiece of efforts to avoid a repeat of the €1.6tn of taxpayer support to banks during the 2008 financial crisis. It empowers regulators to intervene quickly when a bank is weak, avoiding the panic that could arise from a messy and prolonged insolvency procedure. The law took effect in 2015, but markets were given an extra year to adjust to the most controversial measure: tougher rules imposing losses on a failing bank’s creditors, which kicked in on January 1, 2016. This stipulates that 8 per cent of a bank’s liabilities must be wiped out before any taxpayer support can be provided, placing unsecured senior bondholders and also large corporate depositors on the hook for forced losses, also known as bail-ins.

25.  However the EU legislation appears to be better than the FRDI bill in these respects : It does not amalgamate insurance companies along with banks in a single bill / authority, as FRDI bill seeks to do. Secondly, insured deposits are expressly excluded from bail-ins. Thirdly, the portion of households’ and small businesses’ deposits above €100,000 also get preferential treatment These deposits sustain a loss only if all the instruments with a lower insolvency ranking are insufficient to cover the losses and restore capital adequacy. Fourth, once bail-in has involved at least 8 per cent of total liabilities, taxpayer money can be used to bail out banks. Fifthly, it does not seem to require a separate resolution corporation. For example in the UK, the Bank of England has been designated as the resolution authority so RBI could and should have been designated as the resolution authority for banks in india also.

26.  A form of bail in has been implemented in Greece also. With the economy in Greece in trouble for several years, in the beginning of June 2015, it placed controls on the amount of cash that could be withdrawn from one’s account via ATMs. This limit was 60 euros when the average Greek monthly wage is 780 euros a month. That would be equivalent to withdrawing 840 rs. a day in India as our average monthly wage is 10,500 inr. After 3 weeks of being closed in june 2015, the banks opened, and the cash withdrwal limit was increased to 840 euros a fortnight which would be equivalent to 11500 rs. fortnightly withdrawal in india (in the context of the average monthly salary). That limit on withdrawals is STILL in place and is expected to be lifted at the earliest in end 2018, and only if the Greek economy does better than it is doing now, for which there is no certainty. Capital controls have also been in place through this period which means no money can be taken out of the country.

27.   Singapore’s proposed resolution regime, excludes all deposits and senior debt from bail-in. The paper on APPROACH TO RESOLUTION OF FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS IN SINGAPORE makes clear that saving them from failing is not its objective as that would make for non-accountability of the owners and managers of those financial institutions (FI). Its objective is to protect the interests of the users of the services offered by that FI. In fact, back in 2009, Iceland allowed its two leading banks to fail, suffered many negative consequences, but quickly bounced back and now has the fastest growing economy of the developed world. Ireland at the same time also suffered distress in its banking system but bailed them out. The resultant disturbed financial landscape has still not abated fully in Ireland..

28.   In Singapore, as in England, there has been no need for a separate resolution corporation – the resolution function is the responsibility of the existing monetary authority in both countries, as it should be in ours.

29.   As the general secretary of a bank officers’ union says, the most dangerous consequence of the proposed FRDI Bill is that it will take out the issue of existence or liquidation of a PSB (or even LIC tomorrow !) from the domain of public debate and leave it to the whims of bureaucratic dictates. Already, there are many rules and legislation in place under the existing Acts that deal with winding up of financial institutions, United Forum of Bank Unions has said in its representation to the finance minister.

30.   FDRI Bill is also a poorly drafted law - think tank PRS Legislative Research demonstrates how clauses 58 and 62(1) regarding governance of a firm declared critical are inherently conflicting. There are other similarly inconsistent clauses.

31.   Most professionals from the financial field simply cannot appreciate the need for this Bill. The Banking Regulation Act has worked well to help struggling banks in the past – why cant it work now ? Former Deputy governor of Reserve Bank, Chakravarty, says there is no case for a bank failure even if 25 % of the loan books of PSBs goes bad. That is reassuring ! He also gives this great idea of separating wholesale banking (for corporates and institutions) from retail banking (for individuals).

32.   Chakravarty goes on to say that corporates should be funded by markets and not banks. RBI had started this process which has all of a sudden stopped, he says. On looking into what happened, we find that in Aug 2016 RBI announced a number of steps that will strengthen the corporate bond market. Thereafter it was expected that the government will nudge all stakeholders to act in order to complement RBI’s initiatives to address all outstanding issues. One of the reasons why the corporate bond market never really took off in India is because of high fiscal deficit and the government’s funding needs. The NK Singh committee was constituted to suggest new fiscal rules and it submitted its report in Feb 2017. However, the Government has chosen to not follow its recommendations for now.

33.   Murlidharan, who started the whatsapp brouhaha on this bill makes this startling point – if we depositors are expected to bail in failing banks, will we also be getting our share of profit when they are making profits ? (but at present when public sector banks make profits, those go to the Government !). He also very rightly states that bank facilities are merely an essential infrastructure / service just like roads or buses that a government is required to provide to its citizens. The implication is that users of a service should not be penalized for merely using a service !

34.   As an aside, this article a month ago speaks of why public sector banks are special and must be fostered : http://www.moneylife.in/article/tough-measures-needed-to-recover-mounting-npas-of-banks-say-experts/52267.html however private banks’ now have about 20 % of india’s deposits. Their loan books are largely healthy and growing at 20-25 % a year. They also are growing their loans to small and medium enterprises at the same rate.. Even their agriculture loans are growing !

More readings / videos on this subject :

Also this video of Prashant Bhushan speaking on this subject last year : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LRD1cElTqTw

2.     An article published 6 months ago by a senior corporate gave simple pointers to how we can prevent or minimize new NPAs : https://blogs.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/valuesfirst/gentle-steps-taken-for-resolution-of-npas-are-unlikely-to-yield-results/

3.     Former RBI Governor Raghuram Rajan on what RBI is doing to clean up banks : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tvREHPJBDlM

4.     economic times’ debate on the FRDI bill earlier this month : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FXyZMeeqqb8

5.     an interview with a bank officer on the impact of the bill : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6dTnERZPn-o a second interview with the same bank officer : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBOAHzvjJv8

6.     ndtv debate with mira banker : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=amcu0cL2gmw ravish on frdi bill : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ygOgBnB9cjM

7.     shows how the banks board bureau under the RBI has been doing some of the work that is envisaged for the resolution corporation - http://banksboardbureau.org.in/WhatsNew/Details?id=10

8.     shows rbi does the work of monitoring the health of banks and taking corrective action : https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/policy/government-rbi-in-talks-to-shore-up-psu-bank-capital/articleshow/60132474.cms

12.   The best TV debate on FRDI bill I have seen : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oGXREwK26Dk

13.   shows EU-wide rules for bank resolution have been framed : https://www.ft.com/content/8ad2ed98-d0a0-11e5-986a-62c79fcbcead

15.   Shows Greece was considering raiding the deposits even below the insured amount as there was insufficient money in the deposit guarantee scheme : https://www.ft.com/content/9963b74c-219c-11e5-aa5a-398b2169cf79

16.   The depositors in one bank of Cyprus lost all their uninsured savings, only those at the other bank got equity options against their savings : https://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2013/07/29/bank-of-cyprus-depositors-lose-savings/2595837/

17.   Shows derivatives exposure can bring down banks endangering our savings.. https://www.huffingtonpost.com/ellen-brown/new-g20-bailin-rules-now-_b_6244394.html

18. This article says banks should have upto 18 % of their risk weighted assets in bonds that are clearly recognised at the time of issuance as being liable to be bailed in https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/economy/policy/how-frdi-bill-can-save-failing-banks-without-touching-your-deposits/articleshow/62277998.cms

Friday, February 17, 2017

Tips for travelling to Budapest

I have gained so much from others in the international travel community that I would like to pay back. Here are some tips for travelling to Budapest even though I havent been there yet - but my research has turned up pointers that may not be so easily available from elsewhere...

Tip No. 1 : District VIII has had a mixed reputation i am told, but I find its location wonderful - from a plethora of Indian restaurants to choose from, public transport at hand, and historic buildings everywhere you look !

Tip No. 2 : Travellers can take a 15 day or monthly public transport pass which is much cheaper than the 7-day / 3-day / 1-day budapest travel card. I am not sure the host of freebies are that much added value for the price.

Tip No. 3 : You CAN get on top of the Castle hill without breaking your knees on endless stairs. There is an ancient gate under the castle hill, facing the chain bridge. Take the road to the right of this gate - the Hunyadi Janos Ut. This road loops back uphill to the Habsburg Gate on top of the hill in less than 1.5 kms - a scenic 1.5 kms through interesting old buildings. 

Thursday, February 09, 2017

The international travel community

I have been researching a trip to Europe for some time. It continues to be simultaneously a cradle of modern civilization as well as a beacon of light for the evolving human experiment.

I am struck (not for the first time either !) by how incredibly helpful the international travel community is. Random travellers devote a great deal of energy and knowledge in solving other people's problems - atleast online ! Then there are these colossus of the travel community - the man in seat 61, Rick Steeves, but also others who have devoted incredible amount of time, finesse, expertise and just charm in laying out europe before us. There is comparatively little financial gain to be had from this advice, I am sure, if any at all. So it is astounding what a labour of love so many people make travel to be.

I was thinking - that if the nations of the world operated like the travel community - the world would be by far a better place !

Tuesday, February 23, 2016

By these actions were the Jat agitators reaffirming their faith in the Indian constitution ?

Someone has just put up on twitter, a purported list of 29 slogans raised by JNU students. you can see it here.

If true, some of those slogans should not have been used. But these are slogans only - not violent action. Similar slogans are raised in kashmir many times a year. Should sedition charges be applied in Kashmir or should the people there be talked to ?

Whereas the Jat agitators (and countless other agitators throughout our land, at other points of time) have caused a large no. of deaths by their actions, denied the poor their daily wage for days, put ordinary people through great difficulty by blocking roads, and caused enormous damage to public and private property.

By these actions were the Jat agitators reaffirming their faith in the Indian constitution ? Instead their actions remind me of those of the Muslim league in Pre-Independence India which engineered violence across large swathes to force the hand of the British and the Congress to create Pakistan. So it is the violent Jat agitaor who is following the footsteps of those who divided India. But BJP has no qualms about appeasing them... after spending decades whipping passions against appeasement !

Violence by Jat Agitators is rewarded in Modi's India

The votes of students, the labour and farmers dont seem to matter in india the way a caste's votes matter...

The BJP govt. is scuttling to find a reservation formula for agitators who have severely damaged North India's economy and have caused untold miseries to millions.. You can read about it here and here...

I have not noticed that perpetrators of so much violence are being hounded by police - but JNU students are - merely for questioning if a trial was fairly conducted !

This is a good trailer for Shining India that Modi and his hordes are building.. doesnt look like there is respectable space for most Indians in the shining india of modi's dreams...

Wednesday, January 21, 2015

There seems to have been no warfare for 2000 years !

I am still reading / watching Mesopotamia.. Here among others..

Civilized living in the form of settled farmers and beautiful pottery, seems to have begun in Sumer around 7000 years ago, although the first irrigation canals date to 8000 years ago.

Some 6000 years ago, trade facilitated the rise of many large, temple-centered cities (with populations of over 10,000 people) where centralized administrations employed various workers. It was at this time that Sumerian cities began to make use of slave labor.

These cities were most likely headed by a priest-king, assisted by a council of elders, including both men and women. There was little evidence of institutionalized violence or professional soldiers uptill now, and towns were generally un-walled. During this period Uruk became the most urbanised city in the world, surpassing for the first time 50,000 inhabitants.

The dynastic period began some 5000 years ago and was associated with increased violence. Cities became walled, and increased in size as undefended villages in southern Mesopotamia disappeared. The now deciphered syllabic writing started to develop from the early pictograms.

In conclusion then, warfare was not a part of the civilization that existed in Sumer from 7000 – 5000 years ago.

Tuesday, January 13, 2015

Is India the only fount of wisdom of yore ?

Perhaps we were taught a smattering of many things in school, but I have forgotten most of them. What remains in memory are the impressions reinforced by conversations with family and elders, and what we see regurgitated in the Indian media, incuding social media. 

An oft-repeated theme is how great the Indian civilization is with no parallel in world history. That science, innovation and the arts grew only in India with the rest of the world in darkness. But as I read more widely now, I find that picture is simplistic. 

Eridu - city of 4000 people in Mespotamia (present-day Iraq, mostly) 5000 years ago. 

 Image Author : Таис Гило; Image sourced from Wikipedia.

Why have we heard about the ancient indian civilization only from our elders then ? Mesopotamia and the Egyptian civilizations are far older the the Indus Valley and Harappan Civilizations.

The fertile river valleys of the world where civilization first grew – Tigris-Euphrates, Nile, Yellow River, Indus, would all be mighty rivers.. yet we speak of the Ganga as if it is unique. In fact, the first civilization in South Asia grew around the Indus and Saraswati, not the Ganges. 

Pottery from Mesopotamia 6000 years old.

Image Author : Dmharvey; Image sourced from Wikipedia.
The Mesopotamian pottery above compares well with pottery from the Indus Valley civilization, 1500 years later. On left.

Image released by Los Angeles County Museum of Art and taken from Wikipedia.
Uruk city is 5000 years old, also in Mesopotamia. And had some 65000 people living in the city at that time ! 

Temple on the right was meant to honour their goddess of fertility.. 

Image Author : Marcus Cyron; Image sourced from Wikipedia.


Sunday, January 11, 2015

Our Home has been taken over by Doves !

We have always had doves around, but lately we have positively been taken over ! They coo morning, afternoon and evening.. Make sorties to the feeding stations.. Roost on the Shehtoot tree - as indeed I can see one now as I type.. while another surveys the scene from our balcony railing..

These pictures were taken a couple years earlier.. 

I read up a bit about the pigeon / dove branch of birds  - apparently, they bob their heads in an attempt to keep their vision constant.


The guys you see in this picture are Laughing Doves.. common across India..

Two famous extinct species, the Dodo and the Passenger Pigeon, belonged to this branch of birds. 

The Passenger Pigeon was once the most numerous species of bird on earth. 

In 1871, a single breeding colony was estimated to contain over a hundred million birds, yet the last individual in the species was dead by 1914. The species is thought to have been massively over-hunted for food for the poor. 

Saturday, January 10, 2015

Who built India ?

I hv been reading about emperor Ashoka. The story about the rediscovery of his lion capital - which we adopted as our national symbol, is Here. There is only one surviving lion capital in full which was unearthed by a Britisher a 100 years ago. Clearly many Britishers have served India as many may have harmed it too.

The stories of what Indians have done to build India since independence are not that well known to me. There are the obvious captains of industry and those in politics. But who set up the stock exchange ? Who built the ports ? The highways ? The dams ? Who set up the IITs ?

Wednesday, December 03, 2014

The Last Tree

I told my husband the other day that i would see no point in living after the last tree in our surroundings died..

The Mango Tree marked to be cut down when our relative's house was to be re-built (Photo by relative).

That may seem far-fetched but troubling signs have been afoot for decades.. All the old, giant trees in our surroundings have been cut down.. officially for road widening or residences, but also I suspect, illegally, for the wood..

They felt they could not save their much-loved tree.. (picture by the relative).



Because of the stresses caused by climate change and deforestation, large swathes of forests have been dying worldwide the last few years..

One of two giant Peepuls near Reliance Superstore in Bhiwadi.. they should form the very centre of Bhiwadi but seem to be suffering for lack of water..



Wake up ! More of us need to know and love, the trees around us.. they are as much as family as our brothers and sisters.. apart from food and the multitude of medicines and other critical goods provided by Trees, just their presence is reassuring..

Trees are our pathway to the sky.. hugging them makes you feel part of the core of the earth..

The other Peepul Tree in 
Bhiwadi near Reliance 
Superstore..

Friday, November 28, 2014

Two Different Points of View

Two very different points of view on the race issue now highlighted in the US. Both points of  view are valid, I think.

Dr. Ahmed talks here of the police disconnect with the black community and the over-militarization of the police forces when dealing with civilian populations. We say that about the police and para-military in various States of India as well, but in my view they are better than in the US. What do you think ?

An excerpt from the article below :


A different article (excerpted below, but you can read the full piece here) :

Among other things, the author points to cultural factors that are negatively affecting the black community from within : 70 percent of babies are born out of wedlock, and 50 % of all children grow up in father-less homes. 

The Painter who died young - Egon Schiele

In a Blog Post, Beth Caird talks about this major European painter, whom I had not heard of thus far..

http://blog.redbubble.com/2014/02/6-famous-artists-who-died-poor-and-alone/?utm_source=Outbrain&utm_medium=viral&utm_campaign=paid

Increase the size of the text above by clicking on it. 

You can read more about him here : http://www.egon-schiele.net/biography.html. And this evocative piece by Joshua Heineman : http://lala.cursivebuildings.com/post/51804379/the-last-works-of-egon-schiele


This image from : http://zocalopoets.com/2013/10/31/egon-schiele-ich-bin-mensch-ich-liebe-den-tod-und-liebe-das-leben-i-am-a-human-being-i-love-death-and-love-they-are-alive/

Race riots in the US

Race riots in America at first glance in some aspects appear to follow the rythm of Hindu-Muslim riots in India..

The comment in this article on the situation in the US now holds lessons for us too.. 









Read it here : http://dailycaller.com/2014/11/26/who-suffers-race-riots-then-and-now/

Thursday, November 27, 2014

Don't Panic !

The best documentary I have seen in a long time.. please do see it, with your entire family, immediately !

This World Don't Panic The Truth About Population
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wd7K4cgrjng#t=78


Could not some academics please propose Prof. Hosling for a Noble Prize, say for communication ?

Saturday, November 22, 2014

The Power of the Organ !

While out to see a 'Steam Rally' in the Cotswolds in England one day, my father and I came across this :


It was an Organ on wheels ! The music was sweet and folksy and loud ! The organ owner, David, told me that the organ is used at fairs and parties..

On a subsequent visit to the Cirencester church..

Isnt it awe-inspiring ? Picture taken by AM in Aug 2014












We saw this.. A Church Organ.. some 15-20 feet tall and perhaps 15 feet wide !

While the Organ was not being played that day in the Church, I have been able to hear simmilar instruments on Youtube since..











Listen to this impressive performance from Youtube, here..


We have not seen or heard comparable musical instruments in India.. but I understand that the humble harmonium is also a kind of an Organ ! See from Youtube here : Best Harmonium player - Part 2 -  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AAiELn2Intk


Do read the story of the harmonium player in the notes below the video.

The embrace of the Sycamore..

On a visit to Cotswolds England, we were amazed by giant trees in the grounds of the cottages we stayed in.. Sycamores.. they were said to grow to be hundreds of years old.. Taller than the eye could see the top of, and almost as wide, they were an oasis of light green waving in the wind.. The video below will give you an idea..


I looked up Youtube to see other videos on the sycamore tree and found that over 11 pages of youtube search results, there were more videos on cutting sycamore trees than on them !

One stand-out video however, was this giant sycamore in woodland whose base had a hollow large enough for the video author to get into ! See here at Hollow Sycamore Tree on Fall Nature Walk - ThirdChoiceVideos HD - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jIqV3DMs0c


Text information on the net was rich ofcourse.. I found the London Plane, The American Sycamore and the Chinar in India and Asia, to be related simmilar trees.. From wikipedia below..




And finally, this video.. brings tears to your eyes to think the giant sycamore we loved, started out as such a seedling..


Friday, November 21, 2014

Sparrows and Us

It is simple actually to integrate your life with those of wild birds..

Apart from the simple measures listed in the previous post (feed, water, etc.), have plenty of seating / work spaces in open alcoves around your house (balconies, aangans, lawn area, roof, terrace, etc.) so that you may spend part of your day in the company of birds.

When inside the house, ensure your windows look out at green areas (just plonking a couple of potted trees outside the window will do if you dont have a lawn) so when working or resting, you can glance up and notice the birds flitting around.

View from our Study window.








It is sad to find so many people lamenting about the disappearance of birds without taking the simple measures they could to help them. Worse, some people dont seem to feel their absence at all !

As Rob Dunn writes in the Smithsonian (Mar 2, 2012) : ‘Even if you don’t know it, you have probably been surrounded by house sparrows your entire life. Passer domesticus is one of the most common animals in the world. It is found throughout Northern Africa, Europe, the Americas and much of Asia and is almost certainly more abundant than humans. The birds follow us wherever we go.’ 

Sparrows and I

As an only child with busy working parents, the living creature i saw the most when growing up, were sparrows.. i watched them chirping away, chasing or grooming each other from the windows or when i lay in the sun in winter.

Image taken by Vijay Raman in Bhiwadi.

The sparrows were my family, you might say. My parents did not do anything to strengthen those bonds, but my grandmother did ask me to give a roti (Indian bread generally made at home) to the crow everyday - maybe he shared some with the sparrows !

In the mid-90s, my husband and I and our friends, began to notice we no longer had sparrows around our homes, or very few of them..

The newspapers started lamenting about the decline of the sparrows.. We were told the sparrows did not have enough food and water and we started to put out some. But we were not as invested in them..

This image is from the net. you can see the name of the painter on the left bottom.

It was not until 2011, when we had settled down in a new house with a small garden, that we truly developed a relationship with sparrows, and indeed all other birds who visited us. To begin with, the sparrows were few.. but as we put out feed (bajra - pearl millet), drinking water, bathing water and nest boxes, their numbers grew.



Now around 30-50 of them live in our full-grown Ficus tree (I have not counted them but watching their sorties in and out of the tree, and especially their morning / evening chirp chorus give me a sense of the numbers) most of the year.

Sometimes, they are inexplicably gone for weeks, which leads to much hang-wringing in our family !

Image by Vijay Raman. He entitled it 'Why we are running out of Nests !'

Thus I know from personal experience how you can 'grow' a sparrow population in your vicinity.. obviously try and avoid all things that would frighten them - loud sounds, people aiming toy guns at them or trying to shoo them away..

Sparrows need only a small entry hole to their Nest-Box.

Predators such as Shikra (a kind of a small hawk) occasionally visit (they have to feed their babies too !) but it is cats who should be discouraged..

In my earlier housing society in Gurgaon, our plenty-ful birds were all but wiped out by the ever increasing cat population..

It is also important to keep their feed-boxes and water sources clean, else many birds can die of disease.

Shikra - bird identified by Vijay Raman, picture taken by Bulbul in the garden at her home.


Thursday, November 20, 2014

One of the most important videos I have seen recently

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FdQGozSavz8

Lois Arkin talks about the Los Angeles Ecovillage she cofounded and shows its many parts in practice. Its about how small communities can set up their own infrastructure and services, live much closer to nature, collaborate in many fun and useful projects, and finally, do it all within limited budgets. 



This is one among many shared gardens which grow things, there are play and relaxing areas, and work areas such as shared Tool Shops !



There are only two rules in using the Tool Shop - put things back where they belong in 24 hours, and dont get blood on the tools !


Canning of self-grown fruit in progress here by one of the community members. 



The young inhabit the complex, as well as the old. We generally self-centered North Indians have a lot to learn from this successful experiment.

Kirsten Dirksen uploaded this ecovillage video as well as scores of others that i have been watching recently, on tiny homes and self-help initiatives.